Tango Lyrics 101--A Quiz: Do you know what you are dancing to?
As La Tanguera cruises the Milongas of many cities in the U.S., she cannot help but wonder... "Do all these dancers know what they are really dancing to?"
As a native spanish speaker, I cannot possibly conceive the Tango to be complete without its lyrics. Whatever words are pronounced by the beautiful voices of Podestá, Castillo, Echagüe and so many other legendary Tango singers resonate inside me as I dance, and have much, much to do with my interpretation of the song as I follow my leader...
Because of this, I have, in the past, wondered to what extent the understanding of Tango lyrics--or lack thereof-- determines the depth of the Tango experience for dancers who do not speak Spanish, particularly those in communities outside Argentina. From my vantage point--and likely, from that of most Spanish speakers--a very significant part of the "spirit" of the Tango is reflected in such lyrics and, as a result, much of this spirit is lost when the lyrics are not understood.
Or, as my very Argentinean friend TanGuillo put it in a recent series of wonderful essays on the essence of Tango (which, of course, only an Argentinean could have written...):
"The Tango is its lyrics. They are something fundamental. [...] Those lyrics represent not only some of the most beautiful poetry of the XX century, but are vital to understand the Tanguero sentiment and thought. [...] The lyrics in Tango are not only an adornment... they are what bring the heart of the song out, and may even be its most important component.
The Tango is a culture. In the Tango lyrics and music one can see the reflection of Argentina: its history, its uses, its way of life and that of its people. The football [soccer!], the cafes, the friendships, the man's perception of a woman, the neighborhood, the mother, the love... and if it is true that these are life experiences common to all cultures, the way of experiencing and feeling them can be extremely different. Knowing the specifics of Argentina with no doubt can help understand much more deeply what the Tango expresses."
This is so true. Very often I have the impression that those of my fellow dancers who do not speak Spanish--and who do not take the time to find out what their favorite Tangos are about--often dismiss the Tango lyrics as cheesy songs representing the cry of broken-hearted men (and women). And yes, many of them may be about broken hearts... but the approach and the themes emerging in many others are the true expression of a culture and a lifestyle, and may surprise many...
So, now, let's take...
a) A man crying of sorrow for having to leave behind the beautiful face and hair of the woman he loves, as he abandons Buenos Aires for Paris against his will.
b) A man describing the misfortunes that came upon him as he lost the last cattle head he had in his possesion, having to abandon his Estancia and the woman he loved.
c) A man lamenting his poor luck when betting at the horse races--where he has so often lost in the last seconds of the race, just by the head of another horse--and his similar failure in winning the favors of the woman he loves, which he also lost when he felt he already had them.
d) Carlos Gardel showing off his hat collection.
2. The popular Tango "El Sueño del Pibe" ("A Kid's dream") first recorded by Pugliese and later by Tanturi (and, in the link provided, well-interpreted by a Tango-loving Argentinean gentleman) is about:
a) The longings of a young man for the young woman he's fallen in love with, and his dream of marrying her one day.
b) The dispair of kid left out in one of the poorest arrabales of Buenos Aires, his fight to survive and his dream to find his lost mother.
c) The excitement of a young football soccer player, as he gets a letter from an official soccer club to enroll in the team. That same night, he dreams of a crucial soccer match in which he scores the defining goal, breaking the tie and bringing his team to victory in the last minute of the game.
d) The only dreams I'm starting to have are the ones you are provoking, Tanguera, as I fall asleep with this silly quiz.
3. The fun and upbeat Milonga "Toca Tango" ("Play Tango") composed by Juan Carlos Caceres describes the following scene:
a) The social gathering of a group of musicians who celebrate the history of Tango by emulating its black roots in a fun Milonga reminiscent of the Canyengue rythms.
b) The path of the black slaves that disembarked from Africa, were taken to Retiro to be marked with iron and then taken to the mines of Potosi, in the North of Argentina, where their lives were quickly exhausted from the hard work. Those who were not sent to the mines occupied offensive jobs in the city, and were often recruited and sent at the front of the troups whenever Argentina went into war, suffering grave injuries and facing death.
c) A wedding party between a young and beautiful black woman and hear handsome beau, that brings the entire neighborhood into a carnival.
d) The hardships and joys of a young man as he starts his career as a tango musician; every night he plays as part of a Tango Band in a Conventillo, and this opens his eyes to an entire new world of crazy partying. The men gathering at the Conventillo continuosly ask for more wine to drink, more women, and more Tango to be danced.
e) Couldn't care less; I love this Milonga in any case.
4. The cheerful vals "Con los amigos" ("With my friends"), which has a popular recording by Ricardo Tanturi's orchestra, is about:
a) A young, rich and handsome man who describes his constant partying with friends, his playing with women and his generally nonchalant lifestyle. He remarks his unwillingness to give up his freedom, which prevents him from falling in love.
b) A man's upbeat view of his life in the barrios of Buenos Aires, where everyday's hardships are easily compensated by the good moments he spends next to his friends.
c) A man's regrets as he lies in his death bed, and sees his mother as the one and only loyal and loving person standing next to him, despite the fact that in life he left her alone, in poverty and worried for him, while he spent his hours drunk, throwing all his money away in the bad company of his opportunistic friends.
d) Wow. This is such a nice vals... how could you ever come up with such depressing ideas as choices for this particular question??? Tanguera, I'm starting to think *you* need to go out and have a drink with *your* friends... (N.B. I agree...!)
5. The beautiful tango "La Bruja" ("The Witch") masterfully interpreted by D'Arienzo is about:
a) The disenchantment of a man who suddenly sees the woman he's been in love with as she really is--as the spell that she had seemingly cast on him is gone, he gathers the strength to finally leave her behind.
b) The story of a prostitute nicknamed "La Bruja" because of her mysterious past and skill to seduce men into an intense love for her, after which she dumps them, leaving them morally destroyed.
c) The story of a man who losses all his money after betting on a mare named "La Bruja" who races at the hipodrome; broke, the man enters in deep dispair, once he realizes he will not be able to support his wife, his mother, and his six kids, who live in a modest apartment in a poor barrio of Buenos Aires.
d) How badly Snow White used to treat her Evil Step-Mother when they were both behind the scenes and she thought nobody saw her.
e) OK, Tanguera. I'm not questioning it anymore; you *do* need serious help.
6. El tango "El Tropezón" ("The Stumble", inmortalized by Carlos Gardel and interpreted here by Julio Sosa) tells the story of:
a) A man who is enraged by the betrayal of the woman he loves, and is being taken away by a police officer and into jail as he threatens to take her life away.
b) A man who, in his nostalgia and sadness, remembers his life's mistakes in life, including his own betrayal to his best friend
c) A man who is telling his friends, in a little café in Buenos Aires, the story of his failures as he was growing up and how he overcame them.
d) Hummm... at least you managed to come up with *one* more positive theme! About time, too much tragedy so far.
7. The famous "Nido Gaucho" ("The Gaucho's Nest") so brilliantly interpreted by DiSarli/Podestá, presents the following story:
a) That of a man describing to the woman he loves the beautiful and bright scenery of the Argentinean countryside, where he has a small ranch that should serve both of them as a lovenest where to share their happiness together
b) That of an old "gaucho" sharing his life experiences over wine, at the light of the fire, with his fellow gaucho friends
c) That of a group of compadritos in the Buenos Aires barrios; having been raised in the countryside, they long to go back after having their hearts broken by the city's prostitutes.
d) Next!
8. The world-famous tango "El Choclo" ("The ear of corn", here interpreted by the timeless Libertad Lamarque) is:
a) The story of a farmer in the Argentinean countryside who's hoping to marry the woman he loves once he collects the money from harvesting corn this season.
b) A tribute to Argentine Tango, and to all it represents to the Argentinean, regardless of his/her condition or social extraction: the history, the past, the culture, family, the hopes, and love for life.
c) The story of a compadrito in the barrios of Buenos Aires, who remembers with nostalgia those days in which he was growing up, and his mother fed him with nutritious corn-made stews.
d) I think I'll just make popcorn and go watch a Netflix movie instead...
9. El vals "Soñar y Nada Más" ("To dream and nothing more"), which Alfredo De Angelis made so popular:
a) Advices a young woman in love to keep on dreaming and loving passionately, since awakenings in love are always tearful.
b) Describes the hopes and dreams of a young couple who, stranded in the poorest neighborhood of Buenos Aires, expect to escape their misery and move to the countryside.
c) Tells the story of a young, non-chalant compadrito, whose life is a constant party.
d) Awww... I love this vals!
10. The tango "Tabernero" ("The barman") inmortalized by Gardel tells us the story of:
a) An enebriated man, who keeps asking the tavern's barman for more wine, while explaining that only those powerful drinks can stupidize his head to make him forget all his pain.
b) A barman who, working in a cheap cabaret of Buenos Aires, got his heart broken by one of the local ladies.
c) A barman who watches the ups and down of all those who drink at his bar: a sad old man, who lost it all; an old and tired prostitute who has reached the end of her road; the parties and games of a lucky compadrito.
d) Hum. Let's just better go have a drink. I'm starting to need some "sex on the beach".
11. And, to finish the Quiz, a bonus question: "La Cumparsita" is about...
a) Is this a trick question? La Cumparsita has no lyrics!
b) Is this a trick question? La Cumparsita has many different versions, some with several different lyrics and some without lyrics.
c) The longings of a man who is dying of nostalgia for his lost love, and has been abandoned by family and friends.
d) All of the above
e) b and c
f) None of the above
g) I'm confused
e) Thank God is over... I bet I failed, though!
_______________________________
Answers:
1.(c); 2.(c); 3.(b); 4.(c); 5.(a); 6.(a); 7.(a); 8.(b); 9.(a); 10.(a); 11.(e)
Grading System:
9-11 correct answers:
Congratulations!!! No doubt you are a true hard-core Tanguero(a)! A++ if you are not a Spanish speaker, by the way...
5-8 correct answers:
This is still a pretty impressive result! Right on! You definitely have a deep knowlege of Tango...
1-4 correct answers:
Most average non-native Spanish speakers who are nontheless hard-core Tango Addicts should land here...
0 correct answers:
Ahaha. I knew *somebody* would end up landing in this category... Hum... C'mon... *If* you *really* like Tango--as much as you say you do--do yourself a favor, and learn a bit more about it!! You will discover another world... I promise! ;)


13 comments:
I got 7 right :-) I'm shocked! I don't always understand just from listening (if a recording is really old it's just hard to hear, etc) - it helps a lot when I can read the lyrics too -but that's how I learn. :-)
I think it's great that you took the time to put this together. Great job!
Can I play? Can I play? Je, well, I think it will not be faire :)
What a great article!!! Indeed, there will be a lot of lyrics to use to make that quiz... I don't know, I'm thinking in "Tarareando", "Patadura", "Se dice de mi" or "El nene del abasto" (actually that will be tricky even for argentinians, lots and lots of lunfardo). And if we use more moderns tango, like the ones of Piazzolla and Ferrer for example, je, good luck guessing what tangos as "Balada para un loco" and "La bicicleta blanca" talk about.
Your options were very funny too, i laugh a lot with some of them ("d) Carlos Gardel showing off his hat collection", ja!).
Congratulations! I want part two of this quiz! Oh, and I want prizes! Like chocolate!
Besos
I am glad that i got the ones that i have in my itune tango library (6GB of it)right. Two that is: Nido Gaucho and Sonar y Nada Mas, which are my favourites.
Good post. I've been saying for years that the only way I can improve is by understanding what the songs are about so to properly interpret them. Kudos.
:)this was fun, tanguera! I did it just for the hell of it, seeing as I have never properly studied Spanish, just picked some of it up here and there; of the songs you chose I actually knew the lyrics of only one (my beloved Sonar y Nada Mas - I know that by heart), and had to listen to the rest, which was not that easy - esp. those old records, one can hardly make out the words! - but I got 8 right:))) Thanks for the quiz, besos!
Tanguera, this was entertaining and educational. I cannot believe I got any right at all, but I did get a few, considering I don't speak Spanish, and am not really aware of the lyrics while I am dancing.
The story of Toca Tango is very sobering. It's such an energetic and fun milonga. I love dancing to that song and obviously had no idea what it was about. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us!
This is awesome! The quiz that is, not my score :-) Tanguera, you should think about writing a book on the stories of the tangos. I would buy such a book.
Dear all, many thanks for your comments, I'm glad you liked the post!!!
I just wanted to clarify that of course the test was a bit tongue in cheek--as many of you have pointed out, it is sometimes even difficult for spanish speakers to fully understand the lyrics with the old recordings, and so on. Moreover, you may know some songs... just not the ones I selected for the test. In reality, I'll admit that my main intention was to spark curiosity in people to go to sites that present translations of the lyrics of their favorites tangos, and get acquainted with the stories, and the culture. I'm glad if I achieved a bit of that by presenting some of these stories, particularly those that are most surprising (eg Toca Tango). :)
Tina--well, I'm not surprised at all that you got so many right; you know you are a true milonguera at heart...
Tanguillo--no, no, no, no, no. Be a good boy, you cannot play. ;P More seriously, thanks for all the good ideas!!! We are always in the same page, for sure... from Parchis to Tararando... hehe
NYC-hey, glad I got it right for you and got you interested! :)
Methosan--many, many thanks for your post. I wholeheartedly agree with you.
One2Tango--yay!!! you must have a really good ear!!! I also love Sonar y Nada Mas... it's such a beautiful Vals...
Tango Baby, Yippie!!! If I got you interested, you are paying me the biggest compliment :)
Gentimiento, wow. Thanks so much. I'm having a lot of fun doing this for now, and not sure if I'll ever get there, but I truly appreciate the encouragement ;)
I can only feel grateful to all of you who read me (and especially to those of you who comment) for spending some minutes of your day cruising my page to see what I came up with. You honor me with that visit, every time it happens. Thank you.
Hola, many thanks for keeping such a lovely blogg, I've been reading you from Sweden for a while now! Not dancing the tango myself but knowing some Spanish, I've always loved tango lyrics, especially when sung by women such as Azucena Maizani, Tita Merello and Adriana Varela. Actually, I'd like to ask you about the word "tanguera", do you reckon it could be used about a woman singing the tango as well as a woman dancing? My Latin American friends here say that "tanguero/a" is an adjective mostly used to describe a state of mind/the lifestyle of the tango follower. What is your word on the word? :) I'd really appreciate it, since I'm writing an article on Azucena Maizani and would love to use "tanguera" in the title!
Un abrazo desde Estocolmo, Ann
Dear Ann,
So many thanks for your message, I'm very glad you enjoy the blog.
My first instinct when reading your question was to say... But of course that Azucena Maizani, Libertad Lamarque and all those other great Tango Singers *are* Tangueras. Same as Carlos Gardel... I cannot imagine not calling him a Tanguero... :)
But I admit, that your question somehow also made me doubt my instinct for a second... and so I asked with my dear (and very Argentinean Friend) TanGuillo, who's really in the eye of the Tango hurricane, and who simply answered:
"Si, tanguero es quien gusta mucho y es buen conocedor del tango, ya sea su música o su baile"
=
"Yes, tanguero is the one who loves and has a good knowledge of the tango, either of its music or its dance". I'd add...or, of both! :)
So, basically, yes... I think you can use the title "Tanguera" for your article safely :)
Fab! Many big thanks for your linguistic help!
Ann
Wow, this is excellent! Just this week, I was thinking of looking up the lyrics to some of these favorites. Thanks so much for this post!
Eva
Hello from Greece!! Well i hope my comment is not totaly off timing :)
Great blog and great comments..however it surprises me the fact that noone played the devils advocade role..Allow me..
I do not speak spanish. I can however communicate with spanish(and not only) speaking people via body language and general engish-italian -latin ideas.My friends laugh for the incredible absurd mix that i am using but still ,i can communicate almost about anything. As long as i look the other person and analyse his voice and expresion. This is not talent..Everybody can do that.Beides, one can dance a great tango with a complete foreighner..cant he? Using no verbal grammar or language.
Personaly i find your comments and ideas a little....extreme. There are great tangos with no lyrics.You have just eliminate the great di Sarli, and the famous pugliese's themes. The tango is danced on the music.Thats why all of us are straggling on.. Achiving musicality. Otherwise it would be...poetry...or rap :P
Even if a song has sad lyrics and joyfull music theme (it happens all the time) or vice versa, the mind and body is getting the strongest information for act- react.And that is music. Please..believe the words of a non spanish tongue.
Music is the cause , the reason, and the destination. I remember some years ago, when i had a "crush" with tanturi's Una emotion. I still dont get it, why,even now, when i hear that song, tears are coming to my eyes. The theme in that song is so emotionaly strong..After some time i came accidentaly accros the lyrics. And ok..i admit that they fit. But they dont affect me in fist place. I still adore some songs like "jorar por una mujer" or pensalo bien, and have not bother to search for the explanations. Shall i dance a crazy staccato darienzo ,with melancholy, because it describes a lost love? The dancer is devoted to the orquestra..He/she is a part of the orquestra. Not a poet associate..
Oh..and another thing for you and your argentinian.."chosen" tribe.Explain why and how a song dedicaded to a great freedom fighter, who got lost in a political turbulence, is associated with passion. love, and sexuality. Because this is the way that every argentinian performer is dancing "libertango" On and off stage.
(Speaking about meanings and stories of tangos...)
Keep writing :)
Post a Comment